Posts Tagged ‘google video’

YouTube and Google Video Streaming is Buggy

Thursday, November 29th, 2007
Posted in Web · Tags: ,

I’ve noticed that YouTube has changed their player to now do real streaming for the videos rather than the progressive download like they had been since the beginning. Along with that change seems to be the fact its quite buggy and the play head will get stuck on a certain part of the time line and the video will not move forward. I’ve also noticed that Google Video gets stuck when its downloading from its stream for really long videos, most notably videos on Google Video that are over 1 and a half hours long.

Google Video and YouTube Comparison

Sunday, April 8th, 2007
Posted in Web · Tags: ,

Google Video:

  • Signed in Users can tag and rate videos
  • Formats: .avi, .asf, .mov, .wmv, .mpg, .mpeg, .mp4, .ra, .ram, and .mod (no flash flv support)
  • Video Codecs: H.264, H.263, MPEG 1/2/4 and motion JPEG
  • frame rate: 12 frames per second
  • bitrate: above 260 Kbps
  • You Can upload through the website or use the Google Video Uploader.
  • You can make your video downloadable as a GVP file that plays in the Google Video Player.
  • Can embed the video on your site (with the option to play on page load or not).

YouTube:

  • Signed in Users can rate and comment on video.
  • You Can upload video from your computer, mobile phone or record it from your webcam through Flash.
  • You can embed the video on your site, but the user must click for it to play. If the user clicks on the black part of the screen they are taken to YouTube and then it plays. If they click on the Gray play button it will play on your site.
  • Formats: .WMV, .AVI, .MOV, and .MPG
  • 100MB file size limit
  • 10-minute length limit for all videos unless you have a 10+ Minute account.

And here is a quote about the two services:

Why would a user want to upload to Google Video versus YouTube – or Picasa for that matter, which was recently announced?

Google’s vision is to enable anyone to find, upload, view and share content worldwide, and we offer a variety of platforms for users to upload a variety of content — which includes video as well as images.

Over time, Google Video will become even more comprehensive as it evolves into a service where users can search for the world’s online video content, irrespective of where it may be hosted. This is part of Google’s overall goal to give users the highest quality search results possible. For example, some users who do a Google search for Martin Luther King, Jr. may want to find websites about him. Others may want to see images of him. Others may want to watch video footage.

Ultimately, we envision most user-generated and premium video content being hosted on YouTube so that it can further enhance the YouTube experience.

So if you want to host a long movie online, Google Video is the way to go. You can then put it on your site and not worry about people going to the Google Video site (although there is a link to it, its visible and easy to see it). However if you want more people to see it and comment on it, YouTube is the way to go.